Selling or licensing an invention: Which is more profitable?
I hear this question from inventors in almost every initial consultation. The honest answer is: It depends. Since that doesn't help anyone, I'll show you here what does matter and how you can make the right decision.
Option 1: Sell the patent
When you sell, you transfer your patent to a company for a one-time payment.
The advantages:
You will receive money immediately.
The risk lies with the buyer. Whether the product is successful on the market is no longer your concern.
The new owner will assume responsibility for ongoing patent fees and defense against imitators.
The disadvantages:
If the product becomes a huge success, you will no longer benefit from it.
The purchase price is often lower than expected because the buyer factors in the market risk.
Suitable if: you need the money now, the patent costs are a burden, or you no longer wish to deal with the invention.
Option 2: Granting a license
With a license, you remain the owner. A company receives the right to use your invention and pays you a license fee, usually a percentage of its revenue.
The advantages:
They earn money continuously as long as the product sells.
You can issue multiple licenses, for example for different countries or applications.
The patent remains your asset.
The disadvantages:
Their revenue depends on how well the licensee sells.
They continue to pay for the patent and must check the invoices.
It may take a while before any significant amount of money flows in.
Suitable if: The market promises growth, the invention has multiple applications, and you have the patience to invest long-term.
The best way often lies in between.
In practice, hybrid forms are often the smartest solution:
License with initial payment: You receive a fixed amount upon signing the contract and subsequent ongoing fees.
Minimum license fee: The licensee pays a minimum annual fee, even with low sales. This protects you from your invention being shelved.
License with purchase option: The partner can later acquire the patent at an agreed price.
Four questions to help you decide
Do I need the money now, or can I wait?
How large and how secure is the market for my invention?
Can I and am I willing to bear the patent costs in the coming years?
Are there multiple interested parties, countries, or applications?
The more often you answer "now," "unsure," and "no," the more likely a sale is the right fit. The more often you answer "wait," "big," and "yes," the more likely a license is the right choice.
Last but not least, the most important thing
Whether you sell or license your invention, the price depends on how well it is protected. A patent with gaps in its patenting is difficult to sell and almost impossible to license. Therefore, you lay the foundation for a successful outcome right from the application stage.
Are you considering how to monetize your invention? In a free and confidential initial consultation (30 minutes), we'll explore together which path suits you best: appert-consulting.com
What would you choose: the guaranteed amount today or the chance of more? I'm curious to hear your opinion in the comments.
Comments